People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The 24 in diameter pepperoni pizza is so big and yummy, it fed our family of 5 with left overs! ”
“ I was born and raised in Brooklyn and this pizza literally of pizza from my hometown !!!!! Pizza slices are huge and made me feel like a kid again , eating pizza with that authentic NEW YORK STYLE TASTE !! This is Pizza that will JEEP YOU COMING BACK OVER AND OVER !!!!! ”
“ Front cashier girl can be a bit nicer and another older customer just skips the line to buy a beer and she just allows it. She doesnt make eye contact and I had to say Im here for a pick up. Also, the promised times for pickup are all over the place. Only once the pies were ready for pickup. Online says 15 mins, I allowed 30 mins. I get there and they say 12 more mins. Its been 45 mins and still no pies. No sympathy or sorry for the wait. Just carried on like whatever. Probably stop coming here. Stars are for the pizza, but service is uncaring. Update Cashier is way nicer and more attentive! Love it! ”
“ This has been my favorite place to eat a good pizza in and around Orlando. For more than 7 years I visit Brooklyn Pizza and it is incredible, since you enter they make you feel at home. Thanks ”
“ Today was our first time here. We ordered a family combo special and everything was really good and a lot food for a reasonable price.The pizza did remind me of the classic NY pizza. It has the perfect combination of soft and toasty. This will be our new pizza spot! If you, like me, are looking for good pizza, this is the place, if youre looking a fancy place, not too much. ”
“ I passed by and I was struck by the place had very good reviews... I stopped by and ordered a slice of pepperoni and another from Ham. Its a thin and very crispy pizza . Very friendly service. Its worth coming if you live a little far away to eat a good pizza. ”
“ Pizza was delicious. Ingredients tasted fresh and vegetables were crunchy. Definitely will go eat there again. I got the Brooklyn special pizza and it was great. ”
“ 45 years in business!!! Best pizza in Florida! I was born in Brooklyn and their pepperoni pizza is off the chain!!! Going back tomorrow for another pie! ”
Menu
Stuffed Meat Lovers
$29.89Brooklyn Special Large
$25.29Meat Lovers Large
$25.29Veggie Lovers Large
$22.99Cheese Calzone Large
$19.54
About
Brooklyn Pizza Orlando
Welcome to Brooklyn Pizza Orlando, where the spirit of New York’s pizza scene comes alive in the heart of Orlando. Located at 5681 Pershing Ave, this cozy establishment offers a delightful range of Italian cuisine, specializing in authentic pizzas, hearty subs, and mouthwatering desserts. With a phone number to reach out at (407) 282-0110, you can easily inquire about their extensive menu options or place an order for pickup.
Brooklyn Pizza Orlando is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a place where family and friends gather to enjoy quality food. Customers rave about the enormous 24-inch pepperoni pizza—a feast fit for a family of five, perfect for satisfying appetites with leftovers to spare. Additionally, patrons are enamored with the immense slices that echo the nostalgic flavors of their Brooklyn roots. One customer, Andy Delgado, expresses how each bite transports him back, declaring, “This pizza literally tastes like pizza from my hometown!”
The offerings don’t stop at just pizza. The menu features a variety of satisfying dinners, including baked spaghetti, manicotti, and cheese raviolis, each paired with a side salad and garlic knots to enhance the dining experience for around $11.49. For those craving something different, the baked lasagna and eggplant parmigiana will not disappoint. There’s a comforting familiarity in these dishes, serving as a nod to traditional Italian cooking that warms the heart.
- Customer Favorites:
- Pizza Sub - Lusciously stuffed with provolone and pizza sauce for only $10.34.
- Baked Spaghetti - A classic comfort meal that includes a side salad and garlic knots.
- Manicotti - A delectable option for pasta lovers.
- Refreshing Beverages: Pair your meal with a 2-liter soda like Coke, Sprite, or Fanta for just $5.74.
While the flavors are undeniable, some patrons have shared feedback regarding service efficiency. Comments suggest a tendency for longer wait times, but the recent improvements in staff demeanor have garnered positive responses. A returning customer praised the enhanced attention and care from cashiers, indicating that the restaurant is collectively striving for a welcoming environment.
If you’re on the hunt for authentic New York-style pizza in Orlando, look no further than Brooklyn Pizza Orlando. This restaurant doesn’t just serve food; it serves up nostalgia, happiness, and a taste of home. Whether you dine in or take out, the delicious offerings guarantee a memorable meal that will keep you coming back for more.
Book a table